Creation Science Issues – Fossil Footprints
In an article by Leonard Brand and James Florence, titled Stratigraphic Distribution of Vertebrate Fossil Footprints Compared with Body Fossils (Footnote 1), the authors do a fascinating study of fossil footprint sites, and correlate them with the distribution of actual fossils. Fossil footprints are not true fossils, and are more correctly identified by the term “trace fossil.” True fossils are the actual remains of the animal.
In their comparison, they show that the quantity of bird and mammal fossils correlate with the number of trace fossils. In other words, where you see a large quantity of fossils in the rock record, you have a corresponding number of trace fossil footprints. However, when comparing reptile, amphibian, and dinosaur trace fossils, they do not correspond to the number of actual fossils in the rock record.
They equate this to the fact that during the first part of the flood (the Triassic sediments) the dinosaurs were more active, and during the later part of the flood (upper Jurassic and Cretaceous sediments) there were very few live amphibians or reptiles to produce footprints, except for the large dinosaurs. (This is contrasted with the young earth creationist book, Grand Canyon: Monument to Catastrophe, in which all the Triassic, Jurassic, and Cretaceous sediments are all “late flood.”)
Rebuttal
There are several problems with this theory. As any paleontologist knows, fossils are a hit and miss scenario. We consider ourselves lucky when we find a dinosaur fossil. However, we have found many mass dinosaur graves in the Jurassic and Cretaceous, which skews the data. Conditions were right for the mass burial of these bones by fluvial, river systems (not ocean systems, or global Flood related). We may yet discover unknown trackways, or great abundances of Triassic fossils which makes the correlation closer. We are lucky to have found the trackways that we have, and I’m certain there are many more we can’t see because they are covered by other rock layers.
Second, and more importantly, if the Flood model is to be believed, ALL the dinosaurs had to be killed during the first 40 days of the flood. At day 40, when the rain stopped, the water was at its deepest. Why then do we have footprint trackways in multiple rock strata, on top of each other? By the time the second, higher layer was deposited, all the dinosaurs should have been dead…then who was making these tracks? It is evident from Stratigraphy, that you can’t lay down all the rock layers in the world during the 370 days of Noah’s Flood. In many instances, you have fossil trackways, in a lacustrine system, covered by other sediments, then another trackway in a later lacustrine system. This would require fluctuating sea levels during the flood, but during the flood, the waters rose for 40 days, then they receded for 330 days…no fluctuation.
Third, the authors propose the Triassic sediments were deposited during the early flood. Look at the leading Flood model proposed by the Institute for Creation Research, in their book Grand Canyon: Monument to Catastrophe. They claim the rocks of the Grand Canyon were deposited early in the Flood, and the rocks above this point, which show up north of the Canyon, were deposited during the receding of the floodwaters (Figure 4.1 of the book). These “receding” rock layers included the Triassic layers. Genesis 7:24 states the waters were at their maximum for 150 days. All the rocks which contain dinosaur fossils and footprints were deposited in this receding phase of the Flood, more than 150 days after the Flood started. Genesis 7:21-23 states that all living flesh died during the first 150-day prevailing period of the flood. How then are dinosaurs making footprints, during the receding phase of the flood! God SAID in Genesis 7:21-23 that they were dead! The fact that we even have footprints is conclusive proof that the Flood did not create all these rock layers.
Finally, the authors left out a key piece of information, that being the paleoenvironment. Were the environments of the time conducive to making footprints? You would have to consider this in order for their study to be conclusive.
Conclusion
The authors conclude “that the footprint data make a very natural fit with a global flood model.” Actually, the global flood model fails to adequately explain the existence of trackways in late-flood sediments. I admit that this is dependent upon which “flood model” you believe in.
FOOTNOTES:
1 Stratigraphic Distribution of Vertebrate Fossil Footprints Compared with Body Fossils (www.grisda.org/origins/09067.htm)
About the Author
Greg Neyman is the founder of the website ministry Answers In Creation. The original location of this article is here.
Reptile fossil provides missing link
|
|
REPTILE – FAME AND FOSSILS $15.56 |
|
|
MIDDLE TRIASSIC KEICHOUSAURUS REPTILE FOSSIL IN FRAME $1,999.99 |
|
|
MIDDLE TRIASSIC KEICHOUSAURUS REPTILE FOSSIL IN FRAME $1,999.99 |
|
|
Dinosaur Fossil – Reptile – Maxi Card – AUSTRALIA 1997 $4.00 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 2 3/4″ 70mm C14 200 Auctions $1.63 |
|
|
LOVELY EOCENE MARINE REPTILE BONE L@@K FOSSILS DINOSAUR!!!!!!!! $4.70 |
|
|
TR319- EOCENE MARINE REPTILE BIG TOOTH ON MATRIX – AA++ $35.00 |
|
|
PERMIAN REPTILE TRACKS, COCONINO FORMATION #16 $34.95 |
|
|
Triassic Keichousaurus genuine real reptile Fossil $55.00 |
|
|
FOSSIL PERMIAN REPTILE SCLEROCEPHALUS SKELETON SKULL ASSOCIATED MATRIX GERMANY $3,999.00 |
|
|
Germany 1990 Dinosaurs/Fossils/Reptiles shtlt (n29165) $3.06 |
|
|
TR314- EOCENE MARINE REPTILE TOOTH – Mosasaurus $35.00 |
|
|
TR320- EOCENE MARINE REPTILE TEETH – Mosasaurus $45.00 |
|
|
Mesozoic Fossil Cretaceous Period Guide Reptile Mollusk $29.99 |
|
|
Rare Triassic Keichousaurus Hui Dinosaur Reptile Fossil $137.77 |
|
|
7″ Pre Dinosaur RARE EARLY INSECT FOSSIL REPTILE MYRIAPOD TRACKS Footprint 315MY $299.99 |
|
|
Triassic Keichousaurus genuine real reptile Fossil $49.99 |
|
|
IDD fossils medium Mosasaur fossil tooth marine reptile Dinosaur age teeth 35mm $11.79 |
|
|
Cretaceous Hell Creek dinosaur shark reptile tooth bone matrix sample Montana $19.99 |
|
|
Cretaceous Plesiosaur marine reptile vertebrae Morocco Excellent Plesiosaurus $39.99 |
|
|
Permian Richard’s Spur Captorhinus reptile rich matrix sample 125ml Oklahoma $19.99 |
|
|
Triassic Bull Canyon 10 assorted reptile amphibian jaws with teeth New Mexico $9.99 |
|
|
Triassic Bull Canyon 150 reptile, amphibian, dinosaur teeth New Mexico fossils $49.99 |
|
|
Triassic Bull Canyon 2 reptile jaws with teeth from Dinosaur beds of New Mexico $9.99 |
|
|
Triassic Bull Canyon 2 Rhynchocephalus rare reptile jaws with teeth New Mexico $9.99 |
|
|
Triassic Bull Canyon 2 Sphenodont rare reptile jaws with fused teeth New Mexico $9.99 |
|
|
Triassic Bull Canyon undetermined amphibian reptile armour boney plates $9.99 |
|
|
Permian 10 thin sections Pelycosaur Dimetrodon Eryops amphiban reptile bones $69.99 |
|
|
Dinosaur Fossil Coprolite Mammal Reptile Dung Poop Bone $43.99 |
|
|
Fossil Vertebrate Fish Reptile Mammal Primate Amphibian $14.13 |
|
|
*D&F* RARE GENUINE Pre Dinosaur Reptile Track Footprint Cheilichnus 280 million! $8.64 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung HUGE SALE 100 Fossil Auctions $0.02 |
|
|
*D&F* Wholesale Lot UNREPAIRED Mosasaurs Fossil Dinosaur Age Reptile Teeth 1p $11.79 |
|
|
Ichtyosaur fossil Vertebra, dinosaur fossils bones, Marine reptile $1.56 |
|
|
Keichousaurus Hui Fossil, dinosaur reptile fossils $44.65 |
|
|
Triassic Keichousaurus genuine real reptile baby Fossil $49.99 |
|
|
Museum-quality cast of Permian (pre-dinosaur) REPTILE TRACKWAY $16.00 |
|
|
2 best Triassic Keichousaurus genuine real reptile Fossil free frame $299.99 |
|
|
E326- CRETACEOUS MARINE REPTILE MOSASAUR TOOTH + FISH VERTEBRA $20.00 |
|
|
E596- CRETACEOUS MARINE REPTILE MOSASAUR TOOTH ON ROCK $20.00 |
|
|
Rare Triassic Keichousaurus Hui Dinosaur Reptile Fossil $137.77 |
|
|
DUTCH Triassic Reptile Trace Rhynchosauroides Netherlands Ichnofossil $54.99 |
|
|
brown FOSSIL LEATHER BELT S SMALL reptile design $16.50 |
|
|
B.J.F Keichousaurus hui Dinosaur aquatic reptile fossil $290.87 |
|
|
Triassic Keichousaurus genuine real reptile baby Fossil $69.99 |
|
|
FOSSIL EEUC Black Reptile Print & Pebbled Soft Leather Handbag $22.99 |
|
|
15 MOSASAUR VERTEBRAES TEXAS FOSSILS MARINE REPTILE DINOSAUR AGE CRETACEOUS LOT $75.00 |
|
|
4 WIERD OR UNUSUAL BONES TEXAS FOSSIL LOT DINOSAUR AGE CRETACEOUS MARINE REPTILE $12.99 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3 5/8″ 92mm C4 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 4 3/8″ 112mm C5 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3 3/8″ 85mm C6 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 2 7/8″ 73mm C7 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3 1/8″ 80mm C8 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3 1/2″ 90mm C9 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 4″ 102mm C10 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3 1/4″ 83mm C11 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3″ 76mm C12 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 4 1/8″ 108mm C13 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3 1/4″ 83mm C15 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 2 1/2″ 63mm C18 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 2 3/4″ 70mm C19 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 3 3/8″ 86mm C20 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
*D&F* HUGE Genuine Fossil Reptile Coprolite Dung 2 3/4″ 70mm C21 200 Auctions $47.07 |
|
|
REPTILE Fame And Fossils CD Hope Allah S&M 11 trks $4.86 |
|
|
Fish & Marine Reptile Fossil Collection – 45 to 70 Million Years Old , $44.99 |
|
|
Triassic Keichousaurus genuine real reptile Fossil $55.00 |
|
|
Cretaceous reptile claw – Gobi Desert – Central Asia fossil $200.00 |
|
|
Morocco 100% Natural REAL Raw Reptile Dinosaur Fossil MosasaurTooth Specimen #19 $7.95 |
|
|
Triassic Keichousaurus genuine real reptile Fossil $49.99 |
|
|
MOSASAUR JAW SECTION ONE TOOTH SOCKET TEXAS FOSSIL MARINE REPTILE DINOSAUR AGE $16.70 |
|
|
5 MOSASAUR RIB BONES TEXAS FOSSIL LOT DINOSAUR AGE CRETACEOUS MARINE REPTILE $9.99 |
|
|
20 PIECES OF MARINE REPTILE BONE LOT TEXAS FOSSIL MOSASAUR DINOSAUR AGE MUST SEE $9.99 |
|
|
Catalogue of Fossil Mammals, Birds, Reptiles, and Amphi $21.48 |
|
|
triassica KEICHOUSAURUS HUI reptile fossil ** NEW BOOK PUBLISHED! ** $49.99 |
|
|
IDD fossils real Dinosaur age tooth Mosasaur reptile s $9.00 |
|
|
Lizards Dinosaur Reptile Lizard Novelty Money Bill #071 $1.00 |
|
|
Small Crested Nyctosaur KJ2 Flying Reptile $80,000.00 |
|
|
5″ Pre Dinosaur AMPHIBIAN & REPTILE FOOTPRINTS Tracks ! $79.99 |
|
|
8″ Pre Dinosaur 4 NOTALACERTA EARLY REPTILE FOOTPRINTS 315 Million Years Tracks $99.99 |
|
|
NEW A Guide to the Fossil Reptiles and Fishes in the De $14.03 |
|
|
Morocco 100% Natural REAL Raw Reptile Dinosaur Fossil MosasaurTooth Specimen #20 $7.95 |
|
|
Namibia 1995 Fossils/Birds/Reptiles 4v set ref:b1381 $5.74 |
|
|
#17 Morocco 100% Natural REAL Raw Reptile Dinosaur Fossil MosasaurTooth Specimen $7.95 |
|
|
Hall of Dinosaurs Fossil Reptiles Diplodocus Longus Smithsonian Postcard $5.94 |
|
|
#13 Morocco 100% Natural REAL Raw Reptile Dinosaur Fossil MosasaurTooth Specimen $8.95 |
|
|
FOSSIL SMALL BLACK REPTILE LEATHER BELT W SILVER METAL INSETS CHIC $28.50 |
|
|
#15 Morocco 100% Natural REAL Raw Reptile Dinosaur Fossil MosasaurTooth Specimen $7.95 |
|
|
D’ORBIGNY EXTINCT ANIMAL REPTILE PRINT FOSSIL PREHISTORIC SKELETON PTERODACTYLUS $22.99 |
|
|
NWT Fossil Maddox Reptile Embossed Oatmeal Leather Satchel/Crossbody Bag $208 $168.00 |
|
|
Australian Opal – Plesiosaur Dinosaur / Reptile Opalised Bones, 86 pieces, 48ozs $55,000.00 |
|
|
#10 Morocco 100% Natural REAL Raw Reptile Dinosaur Fossil MosasaurTooth Specimen $7.95 |
|
|
BASILEMYS TURTLE SHELL, Plastron Real WYOMING FOSSILS Cretaceous Reptile Fossils $28.00 |
|
|
5+” Pre Dinosaur EARLY REPTILE FOOTPRINT NOTALACERTA Track 315 Million Years Old $36.99 |
|
|
repair reptile fossil,SINOHYDROSAURUS skeleton $175.00 |
|
|
repair reptile fossil,SINOHYDROSAURUS skeleton $120.00 |
|
|
LARGE MARINE REPTILE VERT DORSET $31.43 |
|
|
LARGE MARINE REPTILE VERT DORSET $31.43 |
|
|
#9 Morocco 100% Natural REAL Raw Reptile Dinosaur Fossil MosasaurTooth Specimen $7.95 |
|
|
Fossil Rock Cave hide-out Aquarium, fishbowl, frog, reptile ornament. $14.99 |
|
|
Hell Creek Fm. Reptile Tooth CKP1989 $30.00 |